Sunday, July 18, 2010

Again, the gathering is over

Okay, so i completely understand people singing and loving “Come, Come Ye Saints”—it’s not my musical preference (it’s in G major to begin with, never a good choice), but fine, whatever works for you.

But could we please have a rewrite on some of the lyrics? Especially that bit in the third verse, which starts

We’ll find the place which God for us prepared
Far away in the West…

I mean, this isn’t accurate anymore on two counts.

First of all, this is a clear reference to the “gathering” to Utah. However, it hasn’t been the policy of the church to have church members move to Utah for a long, long time—so why make it sound like it’s still in effect in one of our most commonly-sung songs? (I suggest replacing “Far away in the West” with something like “Near at hand, where we stand”.)

Second, isn’t “in the West” a bit relative? I mean, now that i live in Alaska, far away in the west is Moscow, if it’s anywhere. (In fact, when i was growing up in Maryland, i started refusing to sing that line on the principle that the gathering was over, and the land that God had prepared for me was right where i was. On the other hand, of course, during my exile in Utah, i made it a point to sing that line with vigor.)

4 comments:

KRad said...

Always good for a laugh....

Heather the Mama Duk said...

I figure it's what the dude wrote, leave it be. Plus, since it's really about pioneers, I get to mentally think about how utterly crazy they all were.

David B said...

Hey, Heather—where’s the “Like” button?

The Margin Wight said...

I have a dim memory of Bruce R. McConkie giving a talk in 1971 (?) declaring that new converts should stay where they are and not move to Utah. I've always dated the end of the gathering to that year.